Business rate available
3.6 / 5 Great
Unlock business rate

The Atlantic Hotel

2-star hotel 3.6 / 5 Great

1655 County Road 39, Southampton, NY, 11968, US

The Atlantic Hotel
The Atlantic Hotel – Southampton, NY
The Atlantic Hotel – Southampton, NY
(631) 283-6100
Check in 4:00 PM
Check out 11:00 AM

Double rewards: earn Engine Rewards on top of your hotel loyalty points

9+ rooms? Request a group quote

About The Atlantic Hotel

Located on Route 27, this Southampton hotel is 2.7 miles from Tiana Beach. It provides guests with complementary passes for 10 different area beaches. Free Wi-Fi access and cable TV are available in all guest rooms at the Atlantic. Each room also includes a mini-bar. Guests can relax in the pool at the Atlantic or play a game of tennis on one of the hotel’s 2 tennis courts. Shinnecock Hills Golf Course is 1 mile from the hotel. Ruth Wales DuPont Sanctuary is 4 miles away.

Amenities

  • On-site dining
  • Bar / lounge
  • Café / coffee shop
  • Express check-in / check-out
  • Luggage storage
  • Pet friendly
  • Family friendly
  • Wheelchair accessible
  • Smoke-free property
  • Air conditioning

Reviews

3.6 / 5
Great 1000 reviews
  • Engine customer Nov 2026

    A+++++

  • Engine customer Nov 2026

    There was no toilet paper in the room. I went to the front desk twice and no one was there . I did call and leave a message and did not get a call back

  • Engine customer Nov 2026

    Booked stay at The Atlantic through Expedia. This was one of the only times that I have booked through a third-party vendor like Expedia. I believe I paid a deposit on the room for one night's stay (the Saturday of Columbus Day weekend). Had a lovely afternoon/evening in Sag Harbor and headed to the property after dinner. Come to find out that the front desk is closed (it's not open 24 hours) and the lockbox does not have a key for the room I had reserved. I called the emergency phone number on the door and was told that my reservation had been cancelled. No one had bothered to try to contact me to let me know. The person I spoke to told me that they "had tried to contact me through Expedia." I did not receive any such message. In fact, I received an automated email from Expedia asking me how my stay at The Atlantic was going! I believe I was told that there was an issue charging my credit for the balance but if that was the case, why would no one contact me to rectify the situation? There was no resolution suggested and everywhere in the vicinity did not have vacancy. Thank goodness I actually live an hour west, as I could just drive home. After about two weeks, I received a refund on my credit card. Overall, I was really disappointed with the customer service.

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    I traveled several hours and arrived early the young lady at the front desk was extremely helpful and got me in a room immediately. I was able to shower and dress before my event. Hotel was clean and very comfortable I slept well. I will definitely stay here again.

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    We were 4 girls and the room was two bedrooms and another bed also so it accommodated all of us. 😊

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    Sink in the bathroom did not drain. Could not reach staff to request late checkout.

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    The place is rundown. Random things broken or badly worn. TV remote would not work. I went to the office for assistance at 6:30 PM but they were already closed. Turns out the batteries were dead. Thankfully I had some. Nasty used pod in the coffee maker. Gross carpet. Long black hair in the bed and one of the towels. I hadn’t seen a roach in 20 years but I did after 20 minutes in that place. Cap popped off the shower water knob when turning it. No microwave so I ate a cold dinner. Random unoccupied rooms sitting with the door wide open. I could go on. You certainly don’t get much for $200 in Southampton.

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    Lots of parking, rooms were clean and smelt nice

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    This is actually a really great place to stay if you want something reasonable in the Hamptons. The rooms are clean and spacious and the grounds of the hotel are beautiful. I highly recommend!!!

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    Don’t plan to stay here again

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    Staff was not good, no soap in the room, damp and cold. Coffee maker did not work.

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    My only complaint would be i wish there was a Keurig machine in the room instead of an espresso machine. Would definitely stay there again.

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    Leak in the bathroom. Smoke smell, staff not helpful.

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    Byłoby miło gdyby w pokoju oprócz kawy była także herbata.

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    Nice clean hotel in town

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    I expected at least a 3 star hotel type for this place. however it was pretty disappointed for my family. it is just a motel Inn. nothing more. staff was friendly. but they get off very early where we cannot reach anyone after certain time. no staff u can find near the Inn when it gets dark. so I feel so unsecure. so.. pick other place else.

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    No lights on the 2 back paths to our room, cold water in the tub & the jets didn't work, black mold on the TV table, TV to small, terrible mattress, no shelfs in the tiny 24 X 24 inch shower that had no way to adjust temperature either to hot or cold, no place for toiletries on the sink, no extra toilet paper, the toilet seat was not bolted down so we almost fell off every time, no one answers the phone or is in the office when we had water issues. Will never stay there again.

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    Overall the properly was great. There was ample parking available and we had a good time in the pool and the courts. Our only issue was on the first night, someone woke up with bites all over their arms so we thought it was a one time thing and cleaned the beds. On the last night everyone in the room woke up with large bumps through their arms and legs and we were gonna let staff know but at check out, no one was there.

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    Very dated. Sink stopper did not work, and toilet flusher worked inconsistently. There was a roach in my room.

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    Updated motel, with a beachy feel. We booked the honeymoon suite to make use of the jetted tub, which has seen better days. Our room was in the back so it was quiet. The pool area was nice and we lounged in the sun for a while. The place is like a little hidden gem, no-frills, clean, and they make it easy to enjoy for a night in the Hamptons.

Frequently asked questions about The Atlantic Hotel

Does The Atlantic Hotel have free Wi-Fi?
Yes, The Atlantic Hotel offers free Wi-Fi for all guests.
Does The Atlantic Hotel offer parking?
Yes, The Atlantic Hotel offers free parking on-site.
Does The Atlantic Hotel have meeting spaces, conference centers, or conference rooms?
The Atlantic Hotel does not list dedicated meeting or conference facilities. For business event venues in Southampton, see business hotels in Southampton.
Does The Atlantic Hotel have a fitness center?
The Atlantic Hotel does not list an on-site fitness center. Some properties partner with nearby gyms — check directly with the hotel.
Where is The Atlantic Hotel located, and how walkable is the area?
The Atlantic Hotel is located at 1655 County Road 39, Southampton, NY 11968. With a Walk Score of 20, the area is rated Almost All Car-Dependent. A car or rideshare is recommended for most trips in this area.
How do I see the rate for The Atlantic Hotel?
Engine has a rate for The Atlantic Hotel it can only show business travelers. Create a free Engine account with your work email to see it.
Is Engine free?
Yes. An Engine account is 100% free and without commitment, and you can leave anytime. Sign up with your work email.