Business rate available
2.1 / 5 OK
Unlock business rate

The Cayuga Inn at the Finger Lakes

2-star hotel 2.1 / 5 OK 148 reviews

37 William St, Auburn, NY, 13021, US

The Cayuga Inn at the Finger Lakes
The Cayuga Inn at the Finger Lakes – Auburn, NY
The Cayuga Inn at the Finger Lakes – Auburn, NY
(315) 370-9004
Check in 3:00 PM
Check out 11:00 AM

Double rewards: earn Engine Rewards on top of your hotel loyalty points

9+ rooms? Request a group quote

About The Cayuga Inn at the Finger Lakes

Comfortable Accommodations The Cayuga Inn at the Finger Lakes in Auburn offers comfortable rooms with air-conditioning, private bathrooms, and free WiFi. Each room includes a tea and coffee maker, refrigerator, work desk, and TV. Relaxing Facilities Guests can unwind in the hot tub or enjoy the spa bath. The hotel features a 24-hour front desk and free on-site private parking. Convenient Location Located 1.7 mi from the Harriet Tubman Home and 24 mi from Rosamond Gifford Zoo at Burnet Park, the hotel is near attractions such as Skaneateles Artisans (7.5 mi) and Women's Rights National Historical Park (16 mi). Ithaca Tompkins Regional Airport is 33 mi away. Guest Favorites Guests appreciate the bed comfort and continental breakfast.

Amenities

  • 24-hour front desk
  • Fitness center
  • On-site dining
  • Café / coffee shop
  • Business center
  • Express check-in / check-out
  • Dry cleaning
  • Self-service laundry
  • In-room refrigerator
  • In-room microwave
  • Pool
  • Spa / sauna
  • Pet friendly
  • Smoke-free property
  • Air conditioning
  • Elevator

Reviews

2.1 / 5
OK 148 reviews
  • Engine customer Nov 2026

    Don’t walk away from this place, RUN! It was absolutely disgusting! I posted something earlier, but Expedia rejected my comments. Just read all the other comments by everybody else. They speak the truth!

  • Engine customer Nov 2026

    The property was rather run-down and aged. Clean enough considering. Staff was courteous.

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    I was afraid to take a shower, given the old and not-very-clean shower stall.

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    Not a good experience!

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    The bathroom was dirty. The sink was dirty, the tub was dirty ,the woodwork was dirty. The entry light into the room did not work. I would have left however I had already prepaid for the room. The linens on the bed were clean, so was the mattress cover and the floor was acceptable. When going to the bathroom in the middle of the night experienced some bugs crawling across the floor. I believe there were people placed to live at this hotel that had no other home.

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    Rooms full of bugs. Changed our room 2 from no hot water. And woke up to roaches in my things. Had to go through every peice before I could load my truck to leave.

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    overall run down

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    Sorry to say, the place looked disgusting. Pretty sure there were bed bugs. My boyfriend and I didn’t want to leave anything on the bed. We came in, changed for a wedding and went. When we returned we said we’re not staying here. We were going to drive back down to NYC, but we found a much nicer room in the Holiday Inn close by, about 4 minute drive. This place was just disgusting. Smelled like smoke everywhere. Windows not clean, homeless people, and drug dealers on the sidewalks. Just go somewhere else.

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    The most disgusting place I’ve stayed, they false advertise the rooms. They are gross and smell terrible to the point we had to leave and they did not gives us our money back and wanted to argue!

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    started terrible, but the manager took care of me and told me to tell others please dont hesitate to approach management and ask for things if they are not happy. they are here to serve. his kindness elevated the stars. good work. hey i slept and it was quite.

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    We left cause how horrible it is , no locks on doors had use microwave on door to keep it locked , water didn’t work , there was blood everywhere, there was cockroaches on the floor , they gave me a airbed as extra bed and it burst ended up tryn to sleep on a cold floor, the neighbours where up all night dogs barking in next room , place was awful wish I could get a refund .. but use won’t let me message yous , dnt let other people go here .. We left cause how horrible it is , no locks on doors had use microwave on door to keep it locked , water didn’t work , there was blood everywhere, there was cockroaches on the floor , they gave me a airbed as extra bed and it burst ended up tryn to sleep on a cold floor, the neighbours where up all night dogs barking in next room , place was awful wish I could get a refund .. but use won’t let me message yous , dnt let other people go here ..

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    THE MOST UNSAFE PROPERTY I COULDNT EVEN LEAVE MY VEHICLE. I sat in the parking lot for 20 minutes frantically testing to find another place to book. Extremely shady people wandering around the parking lot, a woman yelling outside one of the windows on the side of building, a homeless woman coming up to my drivers side window. The property denied my refund because I didn’t come inside but I WAS UNSAFE. Expedia had this property as a “trusted partner” which is a joke. I spoke with Expedia 7 times about this and they refused to void the the refund denial. An awful experience all around from the property and Expedia. But I am still alive and didn’t risk my life at that property.

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    This place is terrible. There are people living in the hotel and loitering in the parking lot. The walls are thin and windows are single paned so you can hear every conversation. My white socks were black from walking on their carpet in the room. Their attempt at breakfast was meager at best and not at all inviting. We left early and didn't care about them refusing to give us a refund. We found a much better hotel in the area for the next 2 nights.

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    Comfortable beds Not the cleanest outdated for the price of stay in paid less for more

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    I had to check out earlier because of how disgusting it was I’m hoping booking refunds me my stay

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    Great room nice area to go walking

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    The worst place I’ve stayed in over 40 years! Dirty, loud and the bathroom sink was completely clogged. I was so glad to get out of there!

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    The bedding was horrible no fitted sheet. The pillows were very very flat. The bathroom was not clean and you could smell stash cigarettes in the hallway and in the room. The counter staff were very nice.

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    No comments

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    Dirty, smells, and crackheads everywhere, cops beating on someone's door all night looking for Lawrence, so couldn't sleep

Frequently asked questions about The Cayuga Inn at the Finger Lakes

Does The Cayuga Inn at the Finger Lakes have free Wi-Fi?
Yes, The Cayuga Inn at the Finger Lakes offers free Wi-Fi for all guests.
Does The Cayuga Inn at the Finger Lakes offer parking?
Yes, The Cayuga Inn at the Finger Lakes offers free parking on-site.
Does The Cayuga Inn at the Finger Lakes have meeting spaces, conference centers, or conference rooms?
The Cayuga Inn at the Finger Lakes does not list dedicated meeting or conference facilities. For business event venues in Auburn, see business hotels in Auburn.
Does The Cayuga Inn at the Finger Lakes have a fitness center?
Yes, The Cayuga Inn at the Finger Lakes features an on-site fitness center for guests. Additional wellness amenities include spa, pool.
Where is The Cayuga Inn at the Finger Lakes located, and how walkable is the area?
The Cayuga Inn at the Finger Lakes is located at 37 William St, Auburn, NY 13021. With a Walk Score of 87, the area is rated Very Walkable. Most errands can be completed on foot, with public transit and rideshare easily accessible.
How do I see the rate for The Cayuga Inn at the Finger Lakes?
Engine has a rate for The Cayuga Inn at the Finger Lakes it can only show business travelers. Create a free Engine account with your work email to see it.
Is Engine free?
Yes. An Engine account is 100% free and without commitment, and you can leave anytime. Sign up with your work email.