Bonefish Bay Motel

The cabin was quaint, very clean and comfortable. The pool was nice and clean and enjoyed the kayaks.

Everything was excellent from the staff and facilities

I loved the location. How well kept it was, very clean, beautifully decorated absolutely beautiful There was nothing that we did not like.

Love the cabin!!

Liked the location, cabin was cute and clean. Staff were nice and accommodating. Beds weren't the most comfortable.

Exceptional

Bugs in the room Bugs inthe room

The room was clean, very large bathroom and closet. We liked the pool and pickleball court. Thank you for the amenities in the room. I would love to stay here again!

Good location for us to stay whilst we went to Key West for the day Cute apartments, comfy beds Kayaks and bike rental included which was a nice touch Helpful lady in the office Pool area was clean Nothing we didn't like

The room was very clean , the ac worked great , the bed was really comfortable , there was so much space and storage to place our belongings. I loved that we had free access to kayaks and the staff was so welcoming and friendly.

As fotos são diferentes da realidade, mas de um modo geral o quarto é bonzinho. Tem geladeira, microondas, pratos, canecas, talheres em bom estado. Paguei U$151,00 a diária para 4 pessoas. Não vale, na minha opinião. Tem de subir escada com malas

Exceptional

Wonderful place! Super clean and our cabin had all the amenities needed. Loved the tiki hut /grill area by the docks. Super cool that you can use the kayaks and bikes free of charge. Pool area was very clean and the kids had a great time. Staff were very friendly and there was a gentleman out there cleaning g the grounds and picking up trash every morning. We qould most definitely stay here again! Beds weren't the most comfortable (super firm), but they were clean. It gets very hot in the smaller bedroom and the loft in the cabin, but hey - that's what you get for staying at the hottest time of the year (August).

The room was perfect. The was great to sleep on. I will come back again

The room was clean and comfy and staff was very nice and helpful. This was our first time staying at Bonefish but we come to the Keys often and will definitely be staying again.

Amazing experience every time!! I’ve booked here multiple times and will again in the future!!

Beautiful view, clean from the outside but the truth is disgusting I booked a cabin at Bonefish Bay in Marathon through Booking.com for August 1–5, 2026. Check-in was supposed to be at 3:00 PM. I arrived at 4:05 PM and the cabin was disgusting. The sink was full of dirty dishes with food still on them. The beds were unmade and dirty. I marked the sheets with black dots so I could later confirm whether they actually cleaned them. Staff apologized and said they had “forgotten” to clean the room. They called me around 7:00–7:30 PM claiming it was ready. When I returned, they had simply put the same filthy dishes away in the cabinets — still covered in food. The beds had been “remade” using the exact same marked sheets from the previous guest. They never changed them. When I confronted the woman in the office, she walked me back to the cabin and told me it was the guest’s responsibility to wash the dishes, so they just put the dirty ones away. She then sniffed the bed cover and said it “smelled clean.” She admitted they do not change the covers after every guest — only when they “smell dirty.” She was extremely rude and offered only a 15% discount. She refused any refund even though I had never spent a single night there, never connected to their Wi-Fi, and only stepped foot in a filthy cabin. Thank God I booked through Booking.com. They issued a full credit and covered my stay at another resort down the road. This place is a health hazard. I will be reporting them to the Florida Department of Health and the appropriate business regulatory agencies. Do not stay here. The conditions are completely unacceptable.

I liked the crushed rock instead of asphalt paving. Natural shoreline, not a seawall. Bathroom could have been cleaned better. Hair on the tub

It’s a very nice place

Excellent welcoming from the manager.....very clean and comfortable room.....friendly staff and very quiet location...... The place was just perfect to spent a few days in relax.....