Members-only rates
4.6 / 5 Excellent

The Sydney, The Edgartown Collection

The Sydney, The Edgartown Collection
The Sydney, The Edgartown Collection – Edgartown, MA
The Sydney, The Edgartown Collection – Edgartown, MA
Check in 4:00 PM
Check out 11:00 AM

About The Sydney, The Edgartown Collection

Featuring an on-site restaurant, this Martha’s Vineyard inn is just 492 feet from Edgartown Harbor and the ferry to Falmouth. WiFi access is provided to guests free of charge. This is a nonsmoking property. A flat-screen TV is featured in each air-conditioned room at The Sydney, The Edgartown Collection, which also provides in-room ironing facilities. An private bathroom is included as well and offers bathrobes, free toiletries and a hairdryer. Self check-in/check-out is available at this property. Guests of the Edgartown Sydney can relax in the on-site garden or on the patio of the Victorian-era inn. Fine food and cocktails are served on-site at l’Etoile, which serves dinner nightly. Breakfast baskets are delivered each morning between 8:00 and 8:15. They include fresh fruit, orange juice, coffee, overnight oat, curated egg dish and homemade sweet and savory pastries. South Beach State Park is just 10 minutes’ drive from The Sydney, The Edgartown Collection. Edgartown Cinemas is only 656 feet away.

Amenities

  • On-site parking
  • Express check-in / check-out
  • Wheelchair accessible
  • Smoke-free property
  • Air conditioning
  • Elevator

Reviews

4.6 / 5
Excellent 310 reviews
  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    I highly recommend the Sydney to Martha's Vineyard visitors.

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    I loved the beautiful suite, the chocolate chip cookies, the fire pit, and the nice breakfast.

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    Great location and very clean. Staff was attentive and helpful. Would definitely stay again in the future

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    The inn and my room were lovely and a great way to pamper yourself. Staff was incredibly accommodating and the croissants, coffee and warm chocolate chip cookies in the afternoon were top notch. The temp in my room was tricky to control and an extra blanket would have been nice but otherwise everything was perfect.

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    The Sydney is perfectly located in downtown Edgartown, but on a side street so it’s not noisy. The hotel is well decorated. The outside spaces are great. The breakfast is delicious. But the best part are the just-baked chocolate chip cookies that are put out at 3 pm!

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    The room was spacious and the bed was very comfy!

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    The location was great Our room opened right onto the courtyard. There was zero privacy. I just spent 4 nights in Martha’s Vineyard with the curtains drawn the entire time and it cost over 4300 for those 4 nights. It was close to one of the worst experiences I have ever had and the worst value. Do not stay here. I don’t know how it got the reviews it did. It ruined my vacation.

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    Great boutique hotel right near everything

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    Beautiful property. Helpful staff and great amenities like afternoon chocolate chip cookies, 24/7 coffee and a wonderful continental breakfast.

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    The breakfast is billed as “continental,” but it includes hard-boiled eggs, prosciutto, cherry tomatoes and two kinds of cheese, as well as fruit, croissants and muffins. If, like me, you have to stay on business, fresh coffee is available around the clock. If, like me, you haven’t been to Martha’s Vineyard since the 1980s, staff is friendly and knowledgeable about where to go and how long it will take to get there.

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    Amazing hotel, everything was great from checkin to checkout

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    Perfect location they could not have been nicer Check in .. they could have accommodated us sooner But we get it

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    Clean conveient. Breakfast very good but Rooms a little too small though.

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    Easy walking distance to all shopping Very nice patio

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    Everything and everyone 5 star Nothing

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    Great place to stay and staff are friendly and helpful. Had an issue with A/C in the room but staff did try to resolve the issue as quickly as possible. Would definitely recommend

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    Breakfast was very good, staff was exceptionally helpful.. A/C was only but ok.. room had no view

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    Breakfast was a little lackluster but won't complain as it was included in the room rate.

  • Engine customer Jun 2026

    The Sydney was a very quaint and nice B&B, convenient to everything in Edgartown, walk to restaurants, stores, etc. The staff, in particular Angela and Alex were friendly and so helpful to us learning about the island, places to see, etc. We enjoyed the complimentary breakfast as well and the afternoon chocolate chip cookies. :) I would definitely recommend the Sydney as a place to stay on Martha's Vineyard, especially if looking in Edgartown. Lovely inn, and lovely island to visit and explore.

  • Engine customer Jun 2026

    Convenient to all things! Wasn’t anything to dislike.

Frequently asked questions about The Sydney, The Edgartown Collection

Does The Sydney, The Edgartown Collection have free Wi-Fi?
Yes, The Sydney, The Edgartown Collection offers free Wi-Fi for all guests.
Does The Sydney, The Edgartown Collection offer parking?
Yes, paid self-parking is available on-site at The Sydney, The Edgartown Collection.
Does The Sydney, The Edgartown Collection have meeting spaces, conference centers, or conference rooms?
The Sydney, The Edgartown Collection does not list dedicated meeting or conference facilities. For business event venues in Edgartown, see business hotels in Edgartown.
Does The Sydney, The Edgartown Collection have a fitness center?
The Sydney, The Edgartown Collection does not list an on-site fitness center. Some properties partner with nearby gyms — check directly with the hotel.
Where is The Sydney, The Edgartown Collection located, and how walkable is the area?
The Sydney, The Edgartown Collection is located at 22 North Water Street, Edgartown, MA MA 02539. With a Walk Score of 67, the area is rated Somewhat Walkable. Some errands can be done on foot, but a car or rideshare is helpful for most trips.

Why no public rates?

Hotel partners contractually require business-email verification before showing the negotiated B2B rate. Hotel partners offer Engine exclusive business-traveler rates that aren't available to the public.

100% free and without commitment. Leave anytime.

Unlock exclusive rates