Business rate available
3.2 / 5 Good
Unlock business rate

Valued Stay Mayflower

2-star hotel 3.2 / 5 Good 455 reviews

2509 Perry St, Madison, WI, 53713, US

Valued Stay Mayflower
Valued Stay Mayflower – Madison, WI
Valued Stay Mayflower – Madison, WI
(608) 221-9999
Check in 4:00 PM
Check out 12:00 PM

Double rewards: earn Engine Rewards on top of your hotel loyalty points

9+ rooms? Request a group quote

About Valued Stay Mayflower

Comfortable Accommodations Valued Stay Mayflower in Madison offers comfortable rooms with air-conditioning, private bathrooms, and parquet floors. Each room includes a work desk, TV, and free WiFi. Exceptional Facilities Guests can enjoy a garden, terrace, and picnic area. The hotel provides free WiFi in public areas, a coffee shop, and a daily housekeeping service. Additional amenities include bicycle parking, express check-in and check-out, and free on-site private parking. Prime Location Located 3 mi from University-Wisconsin Madison and 8.7 mi from Dane County Regional Airport, the hotel is near attractions such as Kohl Center and Henry Vilas Zoo. Boating is available in the surrounding area. Guest Satisfaction Guests appreciate the bed comfort, room cleanliness, and attentive property staff and service support.

Amenities

  • On-site dining
  • Café / coffee shop
  • Business center
  • Express check-in / check-out
  • Full kitchen / kitchenette
  • In-room refrigerator
  • In-room microwave
  • Smoke-free property
  • Air conditioning
  • Elevator

Reviews

3.2 / 5
Good 455 reviews
  • Engine customer Nov 2026

    nice rooms, never noisy

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    Don't let the exterior or offbeat location fool you. A family-run motel. Freshly remodeled rooms. Clean. Quiet. Plenty of parking. Daily room cleaning. Light breakfast (cereals, fruit, juice, milk, toast, tea & coffee) every morning. Perfect for a short 3-4 day stay on business or a local visit. Don't expect white-glove service, airy posh spaces, or high-end decor - it's utilitarian. Not ideal for families, but perfect for a couple or 1-2 business travelers needing a place to sleep, not lounge. If you're looking for an affordable place to rest at night while you spend a few days around Madison, this is perfect. If you're looking for a vacation-style stay, this may not be for you. The Value Stay Mayflower doesn't oversell itself; You get what you pay for. It is economical, clean, well-maintained, and quiet, with a friendly staff. Overall, 4 of 5 stars.

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    Clean room and bedding. Bed was comfortable but very squeaky! No thermostat in each room, heat, and a/c controlled by front desk. Walls are so thin & highway noise is loud, you better bring ear plugs! Free Breakfast but nothing worth eating besides the fruit.

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    The bed was actually comfortable. The space was nice and neat. The bathroom was a bit small and didn't have a lot of storage space for toiletries and hygiene supplies.

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    It’s a motel, not a hotel, in a shady neighborhood. Some guests had their doors open to the parking lot, which immediately made the place feel creepy and transient. Bathroom was clean but tiny. Shower stall is possibly 30”x36” so any larger person will have a hard time in there. Toilet took two flushes to make stuff go down. A “double room” has two double beds in it, on metal frame, similar to rollaway beds. Careful that you don’t smack your toes on the metal frame at night. No thermostat in the room, so you just deal with whatever temp it is when you arrive. Harsh “cold” white lighting in the room from 4 bulbs in the ceiling make it feel even more austere. Only 1 outlet on the nightstand to charge your devices. The worst was the second doorway in your room that leads to the interior hallway of the motel where the continental breakfast is served each morning (cold cereal and coffee). There’s a 1/2” gap under that door, so all night long you hear other guests talking loudly in the hall, or from their rooms because they leave their door open to the hallway. Who does that? It’s not a dormitory where you’re trying to get to know your new classmates! It’s downright creepy. As a light sleeper, it annoyed the hell outta me, and I couldn’t fall asleep until 3am. My reservation was for 4 nights. But after suffering through 1 sleepless night, I went to the office to cancel my stay and hope for a refund of the rest of my stay. Still waiting to hear about that.

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    It’s very very basic but the sheets were clean and the pillows were awesome.

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    Quiet and cozy

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    Clean, minimalist, room temperature cold, space heater cute but only warmed a small area. Good bed. Bathroom and Shower was a very cold space -- too cold for a 'warming' shower. Additional blankets needed for bed.

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    Good stay

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    The room was clean, staff was freindly!

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    Excellent

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    Excellent staffs

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    We were surprised from the outside but it was nice, the staff is very friendly, the accommodation for breakfast was original and fun. We couldn’t lower the AC.

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    Na

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    Clean and close to city downtown. Staff unavailable during the night or weekend.

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    Don't look for much with the breakfast options: bread, english muffins, dry cereal, oatmeal, granola bars. There was fruit the first few days, but the same three mushy apples were all that was available on the last two days. There might be yogurt. The wooden floors look clean until you spill something and clean it up. Room temperature is regulated by using either the box fan or the portable heater. The bed frames are tall so the suitcases fit underneath (which is convenient since there are no drawers).

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    Good value for money, breakfast was good

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    Staff super friendly, location is perfect, close enough to downtown but far enough out The beds are very generic, you are not able to adjust the temp in room, breakfast was very disappointing

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    Everything was great everything was great

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    The room was nice & clean. I gave 4 stars bcos there was a strange unpleasant odor in the room. Air freshness would help! 🙂

Frequently asked questions about Valued Stay Mayflower

Does Valued Stay Mayflower have free Wi-Fi?
Yes, Valued Stay Mayflower offers free Wi-Fi for all guests.
Does Valued Stay Mayflower offer parking?
Yes, Valued Stay Mayflower offers free parking on-site.
Does Valued Stay Mayflower have meeting spaces, conference centers, or conference rooms?
Valued Stay Mayflower does not list dedicated meeting or conference facilities. For business event venues in Madison, see business hotels in Madison.
Does Valued Stay Mayflower have a fitness center?
Valued Stay Mayflower does not list an on-site fitness center. Some properties partner with nearby gyms — check directly with the hotel.
Where is Valued Stay Mayflower located, and how walkable is the area?
Valued Stay Mayflower is located at 2509 Perry St, Madison, WI 53713. With a Walk Score of 56, the area is rated Somewhat Walkable. Some errands can be done on foot, but a car or rideshare is helpful for most trips.
How do I see the rate for Valued Stay Mayflower?
Engine has a rate for Valued Stay Mayflower it can only show business travelers. Create a free Engine account with your work email to see it.
Is Engine free?
Yes. An Engine account is 100% free and without commitment, and you can leave anytime. Sign up with your work email.

What's nearby

Map of points of interest near Valued Stay Mayflower
  • University of Wisconsin–Madison 2.7 mi
  • Wisconsin State Capitol 2.7 mi
  • Dane County Regional Airport 7.3 mi

Other hotels in Madison