Business rate available
4.0 / 5 Great
Unlock business rate

Buttermilk Falls Inn

3-star hotel 4.0 / 5 Great 75 reviews

220 N Rd, Milton, NY, 12547, US

Buttermilk Falls Inn
Buttermilk Falls Inn – Milton, NY
Buttermilk Falls Inn – Milton, NY
(845) 795-1310
Check in 4:00 PM
Check out 11:00 AM

Double rewards: earn Engine Rewards on top of your hotel loyalty points

9+ rooms? Request a group quote

About Buttermilk Falls Inn

Comfortable Accommodations Butter Milk Falls Inn and Spa in Milton offers air-conditioned rooms with private bathrooms, work desks, and televisions. Each room includes a shower and complimentary toiletries. Dining Options Guests can enjoy a continental or à la carte breakfast each morning. The on-site restaurant provides additional dining options, enhancing the overall stay experience. Convenient Amenities The inn features free on-site private parking, ensuring easy access for all visitors. Reception staff speak English, assisting guests with any needs. Local Attractions Located 5.6 mi from Bardavon Opera House and 16 mi from Stewart International Airport, the inn is near various points of interest such as Benmarl Winery and Vanderbilt Mansion National Historic Site.

Amenities

  • Café / coffee shop
  • Spa / sauna
  • Pet friendly
  • Wheelchair accessible
  • Smoke-free property

Reviews

4.0 / 5
Great 75 reviews
  • Engine customer Nov 2026

    It’s a beautiful place. Breakfast was delicious. What a location! The grounds were a little oven grown, but who cares! Get out of the city it’s nice here! Fireplace in the room was a big romantic plus.

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    Shower didn't even work & the most they offered was $60 in Expedia Credits

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    There were a mix of pluses and minuses but on a whole once I checked in it was a good experience. The property is beautiful, my room was clean, comfortable and the breakfast and service in the morning was efficient and friendly. That being said it was impossible to get in touch with this staff beforehand and they’re running on a skeleton crew, with workers on the premises only a few hours a day. The restaurant, Henry’s, on the property is closed, the spa relocated and the bathroom in the common area was out of order. For what I paid for my room on Expedia I was able to accept the shortcomings and enjoy my stay, but if you’re paying full price, I would do a little research.

  • Engine customer Oct 2026

    Beautiful location and charming inn. Comfy bed. Could have been cleaner in the bathroom. This place could be amazing if it was maintained. Views of the Hudson River were covered by the messy gardens and trees. No restaurant.

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    We had such an amazing and relaxing stay at Buttermilk Falls Inn! The property is absolutely beautiful and HUGE, with peaceful trails, adorable animals, and so many beautiful spaces to explore. It truly felt like a hidden gem and the perfect place to slow down, relax, and recharge. The breakfast was fantastic, and the staff was wonderful from start to finish. A special shoutout to Justice, who was absolutely amazing! She was so welcoming, sweet, helpful, and genuinely made us feel right at home. ❤️ We truly had such a wonderful experience and will definitely be coming back. If you’re looking for a peaceful, relaxing getaway surrounded by nature, this place is a gem! ✨🌿🐐

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    The entire property is in a state of disrepair. The spa wasn’t open. The pool wasn’t open. The sauna wasn’t open. The restaurant wasn’t open. The tennis court appeared to be totally overgrown. A walkway bridge had collapsed. If u want to experience a historic property in faded glory next to the Hudson River with fallen trees littering the walkways, without amenities, this is the stay for you.

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    The view from the room and the room it self were very nice. Would have been nice to have more than three hangers and maybe a paper cup. No glasses in the room. There were no amenities to speak of. Restaurant had been closed for months. They should have let us know. Spa closed on Tuesday and Wednesday. Paths were over grown and grass was over grown. Path lighting was laying on the ground and broken. Way over priced what you get.

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    Great quiet location. Nothing was open but they do have coffee all day

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    Fantastic small hotel b&b. Interiors superb. Exterior could use manicuring. Loved our stay. Pigs, chickens, llamas- awesome pond/small lake and gorgeous Hudson views. Wineries nearby, bridge over Hudson has food trucks; rent a bike. Breakfast superb!!

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    The whole property was very nice and quiet no staff around after about 5 but Rachel who’s the day time staff is awesome. Very friendly and helpful. Lots of animals. Nice friendly quiet area. Perfect for a quick getaway!

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    What a gem! Absolutely delightful with beautiful architecture and lovely room! Breakfast was delicious! Thank you! We hope to visit again!!

  • Engine customer Sep 2026

    Nothing to say

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    I should have taken other recent reviews to heart. The property is overgrown; the path stones are broken, and weeds grow right under my patio doors, making them difficult to open. I received a message saying no one would be there to greet me, but that a packet with information and my room keys would be on the front desk. I arrived around 1:30 and found the envelope with my first and last name and my room displayed on the front. So much for privacy (or safety). The lobby has a musty/mildew smell, which I chalked up to “old house character.” I locate my keys and make my way toward my room, only to find myself in complete darkness. I can't find a light switch, so I use the flashlight on my cell phone to find my room. When I find my door, I also find a switch for the light outside my doorway. I enter the room, and I’m a bit disappointed. The room also smelled musty, had no coffee maker, and had a TV that refused to operate. As mentioned, weeds are growing up into the outside doorway; the bathroom looked clean, but behind the hand towel was a fake nail, there was hair behind the toilet seat, and there was a tangle of hair in the shower. I went here for a “mental retreat,” so to speak, so I tried to make the best of it. I took a walk on the grounds and became more and more depressed. The outdoor furniture needs power washing; the propane tanks stored in my outdoor area were not a welcome sight. Also, the water cooler jug was empty throughout my stay & the bed was brutal.

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    Absolutely charming! From the moment I arrived, the staff made me feel at home. Room was spotless, bed was incredibly comfortable, and the breakfast was outstanding. Quiet, cozy, and full of character. I will definitely be back!

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    The dead wasp on bed was the first clue - first, we'd requested the Sweet Basil room but told it had no working toilet so they gave us an "equivalent" room (Lotus) that was smaller, darker and danker. And it had no bath towels, no cups or glasses, and no working lamp(s). When we tried to call front desk, we realized there was nobody working and nobody ever returned our messages (I had to use Expedia app and then got what felt like an AI-generated response). The girl who checked us in had no idea if the property had an EV charger, knew where (or what) the Buttermilk Falls were, and seemed clueless as to the amenities (e.g. fitness center). The property is unsafe to take a stroll - there are felled trees, overhanging unkempt bushes, and just a Chernobyl-like abandoned movie set vibe. Like an eerie version of The Twilight Zone, or The Shining. I will say the breakfast was excellent and kudos to the one woman in kitchen who seemed to be the only person working on the property. The other guests all looked as dazed, confused, and disappointed as we were. I had stayed here over a decade ago and loved it. I also loved Henry's but that was closed (along with the pool, though at least the website had indicated that). I wish the property had communicated that the room we booked was unavailable so we could have booked a separate room or different hotel. Avoid this place.

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    The pool was closed, along with the restaurant, which we were not aware of. When we walked the trails to sit at a scenic location, branches and shrubs blocked our view. When we showered, there was half empty bottles of body wash, shampoo and other showering necessities. This was $600 a night. Totally not worth it at this time.

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    Don't be fooled by the pics, which are from some time in the past. The breakfast was nice, and that is the positive. This property could be beautiful and I assume it was at some earlier date. Huge trees down blocking walkways as well as walkways falling apart making it hard to safely explore the property (one of it's selling points). Room decor is dated. Noone there to check us in, noone there to help with adjusting the temp in our room (freezing) or getting us a blanket. No response to attempts to contact them at the number they provided. Didn't feel super safe that doors to outside are unlocked overnight, anyone could walk in (and one of the windows in our room on the ground floor didn't lock). Also no staff there in the morning. We read that the owners might be having financial issues. I empathize, but the stay was not worth the almost $500 price tag with the current conditions.

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    Honestly this was probably the first time when my husband and I didn’t stay the full length of our trip (2 days) and checked out after one night. It was very disappointing. Firstly, I believe we were the only ones at the hotel. We did not see any other people except some of the workers. There is no one at the front desk 85% of the time. There is a number to call if you need assistance but that’s about it. The breakfast and the lady serving breakfast was very sweet and breakfast was very good. Very disappointed about amenities! The fire place was not working, some of the outlets didn’t work! The farm to table restaurant is closed and is not working. There was ZERO room service! No one changed the towels or cleaned the room at all! Honestly for this price a night I would NOT recommend at all! There was no amenities available and overall just unfortunately a disappointing experience! When we let the front desk know via text message that we are leaving at 6pm instead of 11am the following morning they did not say a word except “ok”. No asking how was everything or if something bothered us… nothing! There was literally no one at the front desk!

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    Do not stay here. The property is in disrepair and there is no staff on site.

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    There was no staff on premises to check you in or to help

Frequently asked questions about Buttermilk Falls Inn

Does Buttermilk Falls Inn have free Wi-Fi?
Yes, Buttermilk Falls Inn offers free Wi-Fi for all guests.
Does Buttermilk Falls Inn offer parking?
Yes, Buttermilk Falls Inn offers free parking on-site.
Does Buttermilk Falls Inn have meeting spaces, conference centers, or conference rooms?
Buttermilk Falls Inn does not list dedicated meeting or conference facilities. For business event venues in Milton, see business hotels in Milton.
Does Buttermilk Falls Inn have a fitness center?
Buttermilk Falls Inn does not list an on-site fitness center. Some properties partner with nearby gyms — check directly with the hotel.
Where is Buttermilk Falls Inn located, and how walkable is the area?
Buttermilk Falls Inn is located at 220 N Rd, Milton, NY 12547. With a Walk Score of 18, the area is rated Almost All Car-Dependent. A car or rideshare is recommended for most trips in this area.
How do I see the rate for Buttermilk Falls Inn?
Engine has a rate for Buttermilk Falls Inn it can only show business travelers. Create a free Engine account with your work email to see it.
Is Engine free?
Yes. An Engine account is 100% free and without commitment, and you can leave anytime. Sign up with your work email.