The Historic Blue Moon Hotel - NYC

Great People, very helpful and considerate of their customers. Can’t thank them enough.

Very noisy outside. Useless restaurant. Proprietor hard to deal with. Room was cozy however.

Absolutely would stay here again. The staff, especially Kane, made the whole experience wonderful. Location is great, adorable and authentic. Easy access to subway and buses, local shops and eateries are great.

The only historic element of this property is the dirt which is all over the room, the corridors etc. Room with balcony? You have to share it with the room next door. You cannot open the balcony door because there is no privacy. Do not waste your money. They don't care either about what you say or their property.

It was a great taste of old New York

This place did not disappoint! Absolutely amazing!!

This place is a true boutique style hotel. The staff is incredible and the location is out of this world.

The Staff is amazing- shot out to David always! The rooms are huge and the location is perfect

.

Run down property but very unique and great staff.

The hotel is an easy 2 minute walk to the subway, and is in a great location away from the hustle and bustle of midtown, which I appreciate. The room is the largest I have ever stayed in in NYC, and is quiet for a good night's sleep. The bed was very comfortable and had all the amenities I needed. Very friendly staff who checked in on my via text every day. Great value for the price and I would definitely stay again!

Easy check in and very considerate interactions throughout the stay. The rooms was beautiful, clean, and a great place to relax from the city bustle.

What a great stay! Super clean, lovely staff, beautiful historic building, HUGE room, esp by NY standards, great location- steps away from many shops and restaurants. Couldn’t have asked for a better hotel! I’ll book again!

The hotel was good for the rate. The room was a decently big size for NYC. Hotel staff were very friendly.

Know that they are 100% serious about no changes. We were unable to take our trip because my husband’s knee blew out the day before our trip. I called the hotel and they absolutely refused to let us reschedule for a later date. They first made us call Hotels.com to call the property, so I also had to spend the time on that. My bad because I should have gotten insurance, but I was really disappointed they wouldn’t let us reschedule even with a doctor’s note.

Nice hotel in a great location, friendly and helpful staff and a comfortable bed. Would definitely stay here again!

The building itself is a living story, thoughtfully preserved and lovingly restored. Every detail - from the architecture to the atmosphere - speaks of another era, yet it is seamlessly balanced with modern comfort. It’s not just a hotel; it’s an experience, a rare glimpse into the soul of Old New York. And just as important, the staff embody that same spirit: gracious, knowledgeable, and genuinely proud to share the hotel’s heritage. Their warmth makes you feel like a guest of honor in a place that celebrates the city’s past while welcoming you into its present. I encourage you look this place up on Instagram! You will know what I mean... This place is amazing; highly recommend.

Interesting history but we paid for the suite and there is a club right outside that played loud music until 3 am. There was only one person working at the hotel and when we got there a little early we already had a text that the room was ready and code to enter, but were told we had to pay $75 more if we wanted to go to the room early. If the one staff member left the front desk there was nobody else around to help and no security at all. Already mentioned all of this when asked to leave a review and was told that they don't have a sound meter to document the noise of the club. There is no way that would not be obvious.

Very good hosts, huge room, loved the area!

Very friendly, food was spectacular and the rooms were very clean and comfortable.